Wednesday, June 8, 2011

clothes, class, and cleaning ladies: examining perceptions

other cleaning ladies might look like this...

The last few weeks since graduation, I've been working with my mama before my real work begins. Cleaning houses on the Main Line of Philadelphia, specifically. It's quite the experience in any manner of things (learning just how much dirt you can tolerate in someone else's home before you judge them, realizing their three-year-old uses more expensive shampoo than you do, coming up with a polite way to tell them you won't make the bed anymore if they continue to leave soiled panties in it), but lately, it's been wildly educational in terms of how others treat you within that community based on your appearance.

but I usually look like this (minus the shades. And money, of course)

 Clothing can signify a variety of things: mood, style, ethnicity, comfort with revealing skin, and most pertinent to this post, job/income. While my Mama wears polo shirts and old jeans, I wear ratty workout clothes (certainly not the pricey Lululemon yoga pants favored in those parts, more like worn-out, accidentally  bleached tee shirts and ill-fitting shorts) and we both generally smell of Lysol after a long day's work. It is clear that we are outsiders in this land of Lily Pulitzer and BMWs, and I'm generally fine with that. I labor, I make my money, I leave.

But, per usual, the Sheriff can't go anywhere without getting pissed about some sort of -ism.

While shopping in these uber-wealthy neighborhoods, our clothes clearly reveal our lower economic station and particular occupation. Costco, in particular, seems to bring out the rudeness and classism hidden in these folks. Costco is a weird place on the Main Line: despite the fact that it's whole premise is about buying in bulk to save money (like Sam's or BJ's), it's always packed and the customers are incredibly rude to each other, but especially towards us. Cutting people off with carts and jumping in line is par for the course, as is rudely demanding items and assistance from the staff. They have actually sneered at my mother and I (even more pronounced as I run to get the free samples of food), swaggering about in our dirty work clothes while they are crisply ironed and coiffed. We have even been approached in Costco TWICE by people looking for cleaning ladies (one woman indicated she wanted us specifically because we spoke English. Charming). It's that obvious that we don't belong, and the treatment given decidedly reveals that.

Talking to the poor folks who work at this particular location reveals that while at normal Costco locations, the customers are required to bring their coupons with them to get their discount, at this store, people put up such a fuss that they just automatically give everyone the discount to avoid a fight with a prick, trippin' on their own privilege. Costco is also the only place on the Main Line that I have ever seen Hispanic or black people...and they're all working there. They're also nice to Mama Sheriff and I. Is it because they know we also commute an hour to work in those gilded neighborhoods? Or is just because they have to be kind to make their hourly wage? I'll never know, but I appreciate it nonetheless while I'm in (what feels like) hostile territory.

Let it be said, however, that the vast majority of my Mama's actual clients are wonderful people: I have babysat their children, housesat for them, fed their horses, and she has been to their weddings and christenings. Which clearly indicates that once you know someone well enough, differences of economic stature and education don't have to be dividing lines. But at least out in public, with poorly dressed strangers, many people don't give that a chance to occur.

Have you ever been treated poorly because of your appearance? Or, have you ever judged someone and maybe treated them crappy based on theirs? Talk to me.

Much love,
The Sheriff

4 comments:

  1. People who are dressed in a way that indicates a lot of wealth make me really uncomfortable and it probably comes off to them as rudeness, if they are paying attention. In general I think we're each pretending that the other doesn't exist, so it actually kind of works.

    Before I started ignoring them entirely, I used to work in the uber-bougie shopping neighborhood in Denver, and when walking around people were often straight-up rude to me, even though I was actually trying to look nice for my job (at an art gallery). I guess 5-year-old thrifted Old Navy didn't do it for them. But the baristas were nice, and the guys who washed the windows, and the guy who cleaned the elevator in the parking garage (I've never seen such a clean elevator in a parking garage).

    ReplyDelete
  2. Honestly, I think everyone judges and IS judged. I often make comments about women (young and of a certain age) who bleach their hair and get fake tans (I know, I know- all the power to them if they think they're hot, but they look SOOOOO FAKE!) and I'm probably judged many of my relatives because I'm not "culturally Chinese" enough for them (I swear my grandmother likes my Hong Kong raised cousins more than me. I have two other cousins who were born/raised in Canada, but they're boys). I was probably judged by a lot of people because I lived with my parents until right before I got married (it's partially cultural expectations, partially $$$$ (a decent 1 bedroom condo in Toronto is about $250K ($1 US = $1.02ish Canadian at last close) A 3 bedroom house is close to half a million)). I'm probably judged by where I buy my clothes, shoes, accessories and so forth. Some will say that I spend too much, others will say that the clothes aren't fancy enough (When I was 16 years old, my parents took me to Hong Kong for Christmas to visit relatives. I came home with a cute outfit only to have the some HK girls at school make fun of it by questioning me why I bought it there (the store wasn't exactly high end, but it wasn't super-cheap either. It was probably the equivalent of the Gap in terms of price range).

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm not sure if my clothes have too much to do with it, but as a barista I find that people are constantly rude to me. Some of them are cranky and need their caffeine (not a good excuse to be rude to a stranger, in my opinion) and others are power-tripping--they look down on my job from their pricey sunglasses (which they wear the entire time they're inside) and treat me accordingly. The worst ones, though, are the ones who come in on Sundays right after church. Go figure.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I know judgment is definitely a part of life, and sometimes I absolutely judge their rude asses right back, questioning who would ever be dumb enough to spend X amount of money on a purse/a car/a ring/whatever. But for me, it feels different when these people, many of whom rely on individuals in the service sector to keep their lives running smoothly, treat service workers/people not of their class rudely in public places. I make your life (or your neighbor's life, or your real estate agent's life, or your doctor's life) easier, so calm down and get off your high horse and say excuse me, dammit.

    ReplyDelete